Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Any HISD elementary teachers? or any others with concerns about new math?

who's talking here?

blessed 2
justme 1
PilotsWifeMommyof2 1
momba 2
cmi 4
eterry2 2
WhoHoo 1
brown_eyed_girl 1
planemom 8
karenact 1
mamadog53 1
cgwifemom 1
FishinKim 2
MommyL 1
coach'sgirl 1
mdawg 3
CyberSage 1
qpc 16
AMomOfManyHats 1
Pet Lover 4
myself 2
ChezML 1
Bellarue 1
stealth 6
m•t•v 1
cherriepie 3
Cindy 3
humbleteacher 2
nursemommy 4
StephanieM 1
BeadQueen 1
Blynda~JAM 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

qpc --- 19 years ago -

I know you won't be on right now, but I have a free second to ask this question... What do you think of the new math curriculum the district has adopted. It sounded not so great to me and some other parents when we heard about it at meet the teacher night, and I did some reading on it this morning. Every review that I read online (and I read quite a few) gave it HORRIBLE reviews and said that kids left 5th grade 2 years behind where they needed to be! Basically, they said that the kids didn't learn any real math and that it was an experimental curriculum. This is our first year in public school, and this doesn't give me good feelings. So as a teacher, what do you think of it? 

WhoHoo --- 19 years ago -

while I am not a teacher - we spoke to a couple of teachers who are friends of ours, and they seem ok with it. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

For instance, this was one of the brief reviews I found on it. I read many others with many more details, but this kind of sums up what ALL of the reviews said. cut and paste: Here is a partial list of my objections to the TERC Investigations curriculum. 1. It is at least 2 years behind where it should be. For example, my son's second grade class has yet to do anything beyond 1-digit additions. The very last problem in the program, a word problem asking how many times 5 goes into 171 (with remainder), should be a third grade problem. TERC puts it at the very end of grade 5 as a CALCULATOR problem! 2. Important topics are omitted or superficially brushed over. Mathematics is sequential. To learn it correctly one must throughly understand on level before moving on to the next (example, understand multiplication of whole numbers before plunging into multiplication of fractions). TERC covers NOTHING in depth except for whole number mental math. In particular, the treatment of measurement, geometry, and fractions -- three major parts of the elemetary curriculum--- is completely inadequate. 3. In the early grades progress in math is held hostage to writing skills. Many TERC assignments require the student to give answers in complete english sentences. This is extremely difficult for first or second graders, and completely unnecessary. Mathematics has its own notation --- numbers, equations, diagrams --- that are very efficent and are independent of english. Indeed those notations were developed because ordinary english is inadequate for the purpose. That mathematical language should be used and learned. 4. The program actually contains very little mathematics. Yes, there are lots of activities, but those often have little mathematical content. Example assignment: Find a button. Write down all the words you can think of that describe your button. That is an assignment my son's class spent two days on. Such assignments make teachers happy since they are easy to understand and create the illusion that everyone is involved in learning. But the hours that are suppose to be spent on mathematics are often spent on something else. In fact, TERC students do a VERY limited number of problems per week. One simply cannot learn math doing 4-5 problems a week. TERC is a program that is only pretending to teach mathematics. 5. Effective methods of mathematics and modes of thought are not taught. In fact, nothing is taught --everything is left to be `discovered'. That process is painfully slow, and leaves the students with cumbersome, unmathematical ways of thinking and solving problems. They are left to somehow muddle through mathematics without explanations. Because nothing is explained there is no mechanism for correcting errors, confusions, and misunderstandings. Students do not have books so never get to see efficient elegant solutions, or even correct solutions. Parents do not see any books so are unable to help, or even recognize how little their children are learning. The children are aware of this. They are unsure or what is expected and why. They do not develop confidence about their ability to do math. TERC students will hit a wall, probably at the end of middle school. They are not being given the grounding needed to understand the abstractions of high school algebra and geometry. Their options for careers in science and engineering are being closed off by their elementary school program. Thomas Parker Professor of Mathematics Michigan State University 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Here's another video that was put together that shows some actual math that the kids will be "learning" this year with this curriculum >undefined 

nursemommy --- 19 years ago -

I'm concerned but plan to take a wait and see approach. There's always tutoring or teaching her myself if I must. 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

for the life of me, I cannot understand what people mean by "new math." That name was coined many moons ago, and as a secondary math teacher, math is math. not much new under the sun. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

and as a secondary math teacher, math is math. not much new under the sun. What they are teaching as math does not seem to be math at all. Apparently, some states have really pushed it for 10 years or so and the colleges are seeing the effects of it now. The video shows some of the craziness! I plan to wait and see too, but I don't want to wait too long. I've got very smart kiddos, but they shouldn't have to be told that learning math facts is not important because they can just use a calculator. Tutoring and teaching myself is great (and I will employ these myself), but shouldn't schools be teaching our kids what they need to know? And everything I have read says that kids taught with this "new" math are having a hard time with college and that more and more science and technology jobs are going to people educated in other countries simply because the kids here can't cut the mustard when it comes to math. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Have you noticed how very few cashiers can actually "make change" if you hand them an odd amount of money, like $1.17 for a $0.67 item after they've entered $1.00 as cash tendered. Something very basic must not be being taught anymore. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

It's still being taught but not used anymore. As technology has advanced the cashiers don't need to do 100's of problems anymore. They may run into somebody giving an odd amount of change only once or twice a day. Now that everyplace takes plastic it's only going to get worse. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

If your kids don't know multiplication tables, how to make change, calculate someone's age quickly, do a quick personal budget, etc., don't worry. My kids will still let them work for them. They'll find a place somewhere. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

I keep trying to pound into my kids how important math and science are.... 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

My dh looked at some of these links and immediately had me order Saxon math. He said we would just teach them math at home. 

nursemommy --- 19 years ago -

OMG I just watched that video and I am horrified. I'm a college graduate who does drug calculations on a daily basis and I was lost trying to figure out what in the world that woman was doing. My poor baby. 

StephanieM --- 19 years ago -

I thought she was incredibly clear. Much more so than most people that I have seen. Old school methods aren't always best, but in these cases they certainly look much more efficient. 

PilotsWifeMommyof2 --- 19 years ago -

They like to play around with ways to teach subjects. This for math, and inventive spelling... My husband and his brother both had inventive spelling in school and NEITHER ONE OF THEM CAN SPELL!! It is pretty sad. Both extremely smart, one works on Wall Street, the other is a pilot, and neither can spell worth a flip. Sounds like a great program! 

coach'sgirl --- 19 years ago -

My 2nd grader's homework last night was a worksheet that said: "What is mathematics? Answer this question using drawings or words or both." I thought this was a little strange. Wonder if it is part of the new adoption? 

momba --- 19 years ago -

Maybe this is why our teachers said they are not teaching from the book and will not be sending it home. OK? We had problems in math last year. I think we may need a tutor this year. 

FishinKim --- 19 years ago -

Our math homework last night was a joke. 

Pet Lover --- 19 years ago -

Thanks for the post. I didn't realize all of this. I want to be learning what they are learning, so I can see if they are "getting" it. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

My 2nd grader's homework last night was a worksheet that said: "What is mathematics? Answer this question using drawings or words or both." I thought this was a little strange. Wonder if it is part of the new adoption? Yep...that's what it is. It's called "constructivism". The child learns by "self-discovery". (I've been reading a lot about it the last few days) Maybe this is why our teachers said they are not teaching from the book and will not be sending it home. OK? We had problems in math last year. I think we may need a tutor this year. My understand is that there ISN'T a textbook for the kids. My 5th grader has had a worksheet with 1-5 problems each day for homework, but they were similar questions to what coach's girl was talking about. Our math homework last night was a joke. Same here. I am hoping it will get better, but from everything I've read, it won't if they stick to just the curriculum. 

cgwifemom --- 19 years ago -

So are you talking about HISD or Humble ISD? 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Thanks for the post. I didn't realize all of this. I want to be learning what they are learning, so I can see if they are "getting" it. I don't think a lot of parents realize just what the new math curriculum is. I never expected to find what I did when I started looking at it! My friend who is an accountant was concerned when they said there would be no homework, so we did a little looking and this is what we found. There are parents groups all over the country that have gone into HUGE battles over this new curriculum. They HATE it and the kids are coming out unprepared for secondary as well as college math because they didn't learn any basics in elementary school. 

momba --- 19 years ago -

My understand is that there ISN'T a textbook for the kids. She also said that the classroom had a set and the parents can check them out. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

So are you talking about HISD or Humble ISD? Humble ISD....it's the newly adopted math curriculum, TERC Investigations. All the school districts in the state had to adopt new elem. math curriculum this year though, so I'm sure others are using it too. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

My understand is that there ISN'T a textbook for the kids. She also said that the classroom had a set and the parents can check them out. I did read that the curriculum originally didn't have textbooks, but there is a new "parent/student manual" that the lastest editions have. Our teachers said there weren't textbooks, so that is what I was going off of. I will ask though. I would love to see one. 

mamadog53 --- 19 years ago -

I'm older than dirt and when I was in school they had just started "new math". I still don't have a clue what they mean. I have no clue when it comes to algegra but I can count money and make change. I don't care if cashiers only have to do it a couple of times a day they should know how to. Half the time they can even count the change you're supposed to get when it's written on the register tape! 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

I'm older than dirt and when I was in school they had just started "new math". I have seen this math referred to as "new new math". I think it is even different than the old "new math" :) 

humbleteacher --- 19 years ago -

After a week, how are you feeling about Investigations? 

myself --- 19 years ago -

holy sh!t i am pissed as hell, how can i keep my kids from learning this backa$$ way of math. they say the old way is time consuming...what the hell the new way took twice, some three times as long. where can we protest? 

myself --- 19 years ago -

anyone? 

justme --- 19 years ago -

That video was astonishing... 

Pet Lover --- 19 years ago -

Wow...I just watched that video. I think the children need to be taught the old way first. Then if they need extra help or ways of checking themselves, they could be shown the other ways. What works good for one student may not be the best concept for another. With calculators to do the math...and...spell-check to do the spelling...no wonder our kids are spoiled. I wonder if this will cause them to have Alzeimers when they get older!? (LOL) 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

It may be boring but at some point you need to memorize your math facts. 

blessed --- 19 years ago -

Oh qpc! I saw this thread when you first posted it, but never read any of it. I just looked at it. OH my! I can see your frustration. What a GREAT husband you have wanting you to order Saxon. What's even scarier is that the kids are going to come home with Math homework, and parents are not going to know how the heck to help them out with such GARBAGE! I pray you parents get involved and get that out of the schools. That is terrible! 

Cindy --- 19 years ago -

I am subbing in a second grade classroom while a teacher in my building is on maternity leave. I'm in the room during the afternoons and my main subject to teach is math. After only a week, I have a love/hate relationship with this program. I think there are some pros to it, but there are definitely some cons. I WILL be supplementing with other things. Many of the ladies on my team will as well. The children still need to know their basic facts. The TAKS test is not going to ask them what they think mathematics is!!!! 

Pet Lover --- 19 years ago -

Cindy, I am so glad you feel this way! I hope other teachers will do what you are doing! I just heard that a teacher last year gave spelling tests to her classroom, when the school didn't necessarily do it. I am so glad to hear that. Please, oh please, teachers do what you think is necessary to prepare our students for LIFE, not just TAKS. Bless you. 

mdawg --- 19 years ago -

I knew about the math program. But it doesn't affect me in my classrom because my students are too young to teach this sort of thing too. But on Thursday my DD came home with math homework. It was a game. She tried to explain it to us. Needless to say it did not come with directions. We had to go online to look it up. The directions were straight forward, DD had the right idea, just could not explain it correctly. We played the game. It was fun. We were questioning wether she actually learned something from it. We aren't sure yet. She also had trouble last year in math. With the new program, we hope that she gets it. If not we will be hiring a tutor. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

As a secondary math teacher, I love teaching this way. However, I wish the kids could still learn the basic skills in elementary. Basically, people don't like it b/c you have to learn to reason and actually understand the concepts rather than just spitting out steps rules and procedures. The reason people can't follow the methods is b/c they never really learned what long division or multi-digit multiplication is. They just learned the steps to do it. So, when you forget the steps, you're screwed. Whereas, if a person actually learns the concept, they will always have something to fall back on. I told my Algebra students this week that if they focus on the "rules, steps, and procedures," they will have thousands of rules they are trying to memorize. Or they can learn the concepts and always be able to reason their way through. 

BeadQueen --- 19 years ago -

Parents, please complain to the board of trustees. 

mdawg --- 19 years ago -

I just watched the video. The TERC Investions way of doing math just seems like way to much work for the students. I've worked with many children, especially those that require extra help in math. There is no way they could get this method. They would be confused. At least the old way they had a chance of learning and then down the road passing math TAKS. This way they will surely bomb. While I don't agree with TAKS (different topic all together) I know that students need to learn the facts in order to come out ahead. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground