Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Misconceptions about Mormons

who's talking here?

O Nellie 4
Thoughtful 12
Montanamanning 1
smartypants 1
Mary C 1
Fallon 2
bbjones 19
Anderson 1
Hardshell 2
SS (SmilingSurvivor) 1
CyberSage 2
AtascaMom 3
samigale 7
JetSkiRider 1
Zionist NightOwl 4
ChezML 1
*emily 2
Brian 2
2coolboyz 2
Rachel 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

Maybe I should not be doing this, don't want to debate, but don't want to be considered misguided or ignorant either... if in the back of your mind is all the anti-Mormon stuff, and you need a Mormon - or even better - someone who is a Mormon convert - to share their side of it... here you go. It is a one night shot - I don't need to dwell on this, but hopefully in the future I can redirect accusative remarks back to this chat. If you don't subscribe to prejudiced hate literature, then thank you for being a loving Christian, you can stop reading here. “...if the Bible were sufficient for encountering the Spirit of God…” - Cyber sage It was not sufficient for me, but I do love the Bible, and use scriptures for others who love it too… “Also, I know of people who have felt God's presence from reading the Koran and talking to Muslims. Please explain why their feelings are wrong.” No religion survives unless it has some truths in it – truths mixed with error, but truths. If they have discovered part of the truth, they like any other human being can feel the Spirit when they find some little piece of truth. Joseph Smith papyri The deciphering of hieroglyphics is still in its infancy. Those who will hastily excuse themselves from sitting down to a brief examination in elementary Egyptian will hold forth with professional assurance on the meaning of Egyptian cryptograms of the most abstruse and difficult sort. The idea promoted by critics that Joseph Smith's Egyptian Alphabet and Grammar manuscript proves that Joseph did not understand Egyptian is unfounded. To expect that Joseph Smith's writings and translations were always perfect is to assume that the Prophet was supernatural and not human. If the Alphabet and Grammar contained inspired communication, then it would have been published as such. As for implying that the Bible has been grossly mistranslated – the difference in all the Christian denominations stems from misinterpretation, omissions, etc etc… Even if you had the original unaltered text, and spoke the original language, you would be no more than a Pharisee or Sadducee in trying to understand it without the help of a prophet, or the Holy Spirit. Even some of the people taught directly by Jesus did not get it... again, it takes more than just scriptures, it takes a witness of the Holy Spirit. Cyber – “Yet, with the papyri, all we got was one man's translation of a document” That is the beauty of the Book of Mormon, the Pearl of Great Price, Doctrine and Covenants. It has not been tainted by time – there are not multiple versions of it. They are scriptures prepared and preserved for us that have not been through the dark ages, and have not been corrupted by hundreds of men trying to preserve it through time. Cyber “8 people who witnessed the plates, 5 of them became apostates” Though each of the Three Witnesses was excommunicated from the Church for a time (two later returned), none ever denied or retracted his testimony. All eleven witnesses reaffirmed their belief in the Book of Mormon throughout their lives - despite arguments with the imperfect people in the church. As for the “blood atonement” The doctrines of the Church affirm that the Atonement wrought by the shedding of the blood of Jesus Christ is efficacious for the sins of all who believe, repent, are baptized by one having authority, and receive the gift of the Holy Ghost. If thereafter, however, a person commits a grievous sin such as the shedding of innocent blood, the Savior's sacrifice alone will not absolve a person from the consequences of the sin. The sinner must repent and submit to whatever penalty the Lord may require in order to benefit from the Atonement of Christ. Several early Church leaders taught that in a complete theocracy, the Lord could require the voluntary shedding of a murderer's blood as part of the process of atonement for such a grievous sin. This potentiality was referred to as "blood atonement." Because such a theocracy has never been operative in this world, "blood atonement" has never been practiced by the Church. polygamy - is practiced in the Bible... as a female, I am too imperfect - too jealous, selfish, etc... to probably be able to handle that one very well - but if I were perfect, I think I would do just fine with it... Since 1904, it has been uniform Church policy to excommunicate any member either practicing or openly advocating the practice of polygamy. As for women in the church - I am a feminist - a true feminist. trying, not to become a man, but to become a sweet, loving, nurturing mother and wife. ............. I will not be around for awhile (FHE) but will try to reply to politely posted concerns anyone has for me :) 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

Though each of the Three Witnesses was excommunicated from the Church for a time (two later returned), none ever denied or retracted his testimony. All eleven witnesses reaffirmed their belief in the Book of Mormon throughout their lives - despite arguments with the imperfect people in the church. I think it happened, why would an Ex-morman that left the church not come out with the truth just to dispute the morman religion. BUT, I do think that it was demonic or something. I think they were either in a trance or something evil literally wrote it... Sorry, I know I just TICKED off a lot of people!!! 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

as a female, I am too imperfect. . . but if I were perfect, I think I would do just fine with it [polygamy] See, I have a huge problem with the misogyny of the Mormon church. It goes far beyond the one-sided submission taught by most Christian churches. E.g., Joseph Smith taught that a woman will not be resurrected unless her husband calls her forth from the grave. I just CAN NOT and WILL NOT ever accept that kind of denigration. Jamie, we ALL are imperfect, but females are not MORE imperfect than males. Being able to accept polygamy is not a sign of strength, but of rock-bottom feelings of worthlessness if you don't believe you deserve better than that. I'm not saying this out of hate. I don't hate Mormons at all, but I do have a lot of problems with their doctrines. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

wow, nightowl, that was very nicely put. I mean it. But do the Mormons still beleive in Pologyamy? Isn't is outlawed by the Mormon Church? 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

I have a sister and brother in law that are Mormon. I respect them, but I just don't discuss it. There are way too many differences. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

Just to clarify, members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints are not polygamists in any form. I am a member and that is the truth. That is all I will say on this thread. I am disappointed it is even here, attracting the bashings of people who think they know about my religion... 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

If thereafter, however, a person commits a grievous sin such as the shedding of innocent blood, the Savior's sacrifice alone will not absolve a person from the consequences of the sin. Wow, you are the first Mormon I have ever met who would even admit that this was a tenet of their faith. Whenever the missionaries come to my door, I tell them that this is the single most offensive part of their religion to me. And actually, they all tell me that it isn't true, that B. Young never said that. I tell them that it is true, and that they should ask their Elders about it. The last guy that I said that to told me that he was an elder, and that he had never heard that. I told him that I could understand that he may not be aware of all of the teachings of the LDS Church, but that he should look that one up for himself. (Never heard back from him. . . Did they "blackball" my house?) That particular teaching of blood atonement is the reason why firing squads are allowed in Utah to this day. So my question for you, Jamie, is this. Do you really not have a problem with that teaching, I mean, on a personal level? Do you, as a self-described Christian, believe that Jesus' blood was not enough to cover any sin that you might, hypothetically, commit in the future? Do you really believe that Jesus' sacrifice was not a total fulfillment of every blood sacrifice required under God's Law? Again, not trying to be hateful or ugly. I'm really curious about what your personal belief is here. Thanks! 

JetSkiRider --- 19 years ago -

emily -- I have studied the LDS many times. It is not possible for an adult, or a child for that matter, to study the Bible and believe LDS doctrine. Paul warned over and over again in the New Testament about false doctrine. In Matthew 24 when the disciples asked Christ what the signs of the end of the age will be, the first thing Christ told them is LET NO MAN DECEIVE you. Hmmmm, who was He talking about??? Muhammad? Joseph Smith? Buda? Uh, YES! 

samigale --- 19 years ago -

I am also LDS. :) 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

I am sorry you feel that way Jet, I am not pushing my beliefs on anyone. I have a close and personal relationship with the Lord and thats what works for me. I simply came on this thread to express my disappointment in this thread and other ones like it. I do not believe any religion should be the subject of persecution and I don't know why any member of my religion in their right mind would come on here expecting a pleasant discussion. All thats been done here with the initial post was inviting more negativity. I don't believe this the proper forum for missionary work or even sharing beliefs and testimony. I knew better than to open this thread but obviously my judgement was off. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

Emily, I am not wanting to persecute the Mormon religion. I do know that of all the conversations I've had with Mormons (all missionaries) about what they believe, they were all very open to hearing what my objections were. None of our conversations were ever confrontational. I think that Jaime's heart is in the right place, trying to establish open and respectful dialogue. But do the Mormons still believe in Polygamy? Isn't is outlawed by the Mormon Church? Fallon, you and Emily are correct that The LDS Church does not practice polygamy today. They discontinued the practice of polygamy in 1890 as a move toward the goal of establishing statehood for Utah. Although the practice was discontinued, the doctrine is still in place and can be found in the Doctrine and Covenants, Section 132. This is canonized LDS scripture. Here is the link to Doctrine and Covenants, Section 132; note in particular vv 61-62: Official Scriptures of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints 

Montanamanning --- 19 years ago -

I am disappointed it is even here, attracting the bashings of people who think they know Very nicely said.....why is it here? 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

Montana, you'll have to ask the one who started the thread. (I know how you feel emily, I'm Catholic and bashed regularly here! lol) But I do have to say that NightOwl was very respectful on the questions. I don't understand lots of religions, and it is nice to be correctly informed. My cousing is a Jevohahs Witness (sp) and I don't understand a good bit of that religion. But is good to open up the dialog so others can. It is all about keeping it civil. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

I leave my prior posts to the judgment of my fellow readers, as to whether I was bashing or not. Jamie, I thank you for replying to SOME of my questions. I have one more for now; any LDS may answer. Here it is: Is man basically good or evil? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I wish that all of you who are commenting on this thread would think about one thing. Jesus Christ started one Church which was the body of Christ. All Christians are to be a part of that Church and that relationship with Jesus Christ which is what Christianity actually is. All of this talk about belonging to different religions, when all of you say you are Christians, should indicate to you that something is wrong with the concept of those religions. Fallon, I am not trying to bash you, but I am going to use what you said as an example. You said "I'm Catholic". Do you not feel that you are a Christian? I guess that I cannot understand why someone would label themselves as a Catholic, or Baptist, or Methodist, or Mormon, etc. instead of saying that they are a Christian. Jesus Christ died for us on the cross, not Jesus Catholic, or Jesus Baptist, or Jesus Methodist, or Jesus Mormon, etc. To the Christians out there, think about what the world would be like with NO church denominations. Just one church around the world perfectly united in mind and thought, exactly like what God through Paul appealed for: "I appeal to you, brothers, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that all of you agree with one another so that there may be no divisions among you and that you may be perfectly united in mind and thought." (1 Corinthians 1:10) Imagine non-Christians seeing ONE church. WOW ! ! How powerful would that be ! ! !The unbelieving world would indeed then in their hearts say, "Yes, God really must have sent His Son." This is exactly what Jesus prayed for in John 17:22-23 when He said, "I have given them the glory that you gave me, that they may be one as we are one: I in them and you in me. May they be brought to complete unity to let the world know that you sent me and have loved them even as you have loved me." But what does the world see now through the different denominations of "man's" Christianity. They mock us saying "Those religious wackos can't even get that Bible of theirs to agree, let alone persuade us to believe." That is TRULY sad! 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

And bbjones, What is the first point to be made in ANY correct systematic theology? Anyone may answer. Mormons too. It points rather directly to the question I asked 2 posts above. So I will repeat it: Is man basically good or evil? No takers? LDS friends? I assure you there is NO division on this point in the body of Christ. NONE. LDS or not, it must give you a bit of concern if you do not immediately know the answer. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Is man basically good or evil? Man is evil! 

samigale --- 19 years ago -

Man is evil! Not all man is evil. 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

Man is evil! I do not believe that. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

Back from Family Home evening - we playd cards, ate ice-cream, and had a fun night. Might take me awhile to get through everyone's comments - sorry emily, don't mean to offend - I have always been the honest, nothing barred type. You can not say anything and harbor bad feelings about people, or just give your honest opinion, then learn a new perspective, and hopfully people will come away with a new understanding of who we are... none ever denied or retracted his testimony - Knowing the truth, and following it are two different things. Consider King David's sin of adultery with Bathsheba – he knew what was right and wrong, but messed up. Most people mess up – to squabble with a person is one thing, to squabble with God and deny that you felt his Spirit is quite another… that is a pit that would be hard to dig yourself out of, and one the witnesses were not willing to dig for themselves. ____________________________________ See, I have a huge problem with the misogyny of the Mormon church. It goes far beyond the one-sided submission taught by most Christian churches. E.g., Joseph Smith taught that a woman will not be resurrected unless her husband calls her forth from the grave. - a woman will not make it into the celestial kingdom without a husband she is sealed to – a man will not make it into the celestial kingdom without a wife he is sealed to both men and women are helpless to get into the highest degree of glory without each other. If you cannot even love your spouse… then being together forever is not what you would consider heaven, and you will not be forced to go there. females are not MORE imperfect than males. - I agree. There is a Mormon hymn – Oh My Father – that talks about a Heavenly Mother too – it is whispered she is a mother so sacred and beloved, that she is not mentioned in any Biblical or Mormon scripture. If you have seen the things that ignorant people have accused God of, this is what she may be protected from. 3. I had learned to call thee Father, Thru thy Spirit from on high, But, until the key of knowledge Was restored, I knew not why. In the heav’ns are parents single? No, the thought makes reason stare! Truth is reason; truth eternal Tells me I’ve a mother there. 4. When I leave this frail existence, When I lay this mortal by, Father, Mother, may I meet you In your royal courts on high? Then, at length, when I’ve completed All you sent me forth to do, With your mutual approbation Let me come and dwell with you. Women are held in very high esteem in the Mormon church. Some men who live righteously enough are allowed to have the priesthood. All women, are blessed with motherhood – a gift that no man can bestow or take away. For me, motherhood is a preferred gift. Men and women perform different roles, but they are equal partners. As a parable – it is like comparing an engineer to a musician – which is better? You cannot say – they each perform different roles. To belittle the musician because they cannot make the piano they are playing on, or accuse the engineer of being terse and un-feeling because they cannot play the piano is missing the picture. I suppose the musician could make a piano – sure they could if they tried, but they would be doing something that was not natural to them, and something that would not really give them joy. Differences make each person special, needed, and appreciated. A woman should not have to become a man to prove her worth, and a man should not have to become a woman to show his…. Defined, natural roles of men and women are not designed to stifle us, rather trying to give us the happies life we can have… PS – I, a Mormon woman, have a PHD in Engineering Systems from the Colorado School of Mines. I am using my high and mighty degree to be a stay at home mom *at least until all the kids are in school) I am not perfect – it was a little hard for me to give up my career for a while for this – but I know I is the right choice. Am I striving for glory of God, or glory of the world? My daughter once asked me what I wanted to be when I grew up – I said an astronaut – she said “what happened?” I said – I get to do something much better – I got to be your mom. As a female can you do it all? I have not always been a stay at home mom – working with kids sucks. Your heart breaks as I left them with relatives – knowing others were raising them, that I was missing their childhood – it was so stressful, life was not happy. You cannot serve two masters… like eating peanuts with bubblegum – separately they are ok, but cram it all in your mouth at once – you can do it – but both loose their savor… 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

All men are evil! "As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one:" (Romans 3:10) 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

Because no one is righteous means they are evil? Our understandings of evil are different. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Joseph Smith taught that a woman will not be resurrected unless her husband calls her forth from the grave. - a woman will not make it into the celestial kingdom without a husband she is sealed to – a man will not make it into the celestial kingdom without a wife he is sealed to both men and women are helpless to get into the highest degree of glory without each other. If you cannot even love your spouse… then being together forever is not what you would consider heaven, and you will not be forced to go there. That is NOT what Jesus Christ taught and is NOT what God tells us in the Bible. Who is more important to you - the Father/Son/Holy Ghost or Joseph Smith? 

samigale --- 19 years ago -

Who is more important to you - the Father/Son/Holy Ghost or Joseph Smith? They are all very important! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Because no one is righteous means they are evil. Our understandings of evil are different. What is your understanding of the definition of evil? 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

If you cannot even love your spouse… then being together forever is not what you would consider heaven, and you will not be forced to go there. Loving your spouse and being in absolute fear of disagreeing with him for fear that he won't call you out of the grave are two totally different things. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

They are all very important! So you are putting Joseph Smith, a man, on the same level as Jesus Christ who is our God? 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

So my question for you, Jamie, is this. Do you really not have a problem with that teaching, I mean, on a personal level? Do you, as a self-described Christian, believe that Jesus' blood was not enough to cover any sin that you might, hypothetically, commit in the future? Do you really believe that Jesus' sacrifice was not a total fulfillment of every blood sacrifice required under God's Law? There is always the debate between faith vs works… I say you need both – faith AND works to gain salvation. We make quite a few covenants – an agreement between mortals and God which lays obligation on both parties to satisfy both mercy and justice. We do all that we are able to do, and Jesus Christ does the rest. To me, it is part of free will. As a parent, do you want to do everything for your child? Or let your child have the dignity of doing some things for themselves. We are more than just mortal humans – we are the creation of a mighty God, and as such, we are capable of more than most would like to take responsibility for… Heaven and Hell is not a matter of where you were born, or predestination, or some random draw of the cards – it is a function of what we choose to do combined with the Love of our brother Jesus who gives us the opportunity to do it. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

LET NO MAN DECEIVE you We are the church of Jesus Christ - not the church of a man. That is the point - learn from the Spirit 

samigale --- 19 years ago -

So you are putting Joseph Smith, a man, on the same level as Jesus Christ who is our God? I would say Jesus Christ is important but Joseph Smith is very important as well! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I say you need both – faith AND works to gain salvation. God says that we do not. "For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that NOT OF YOURSELVES: it is the gift of God: NOT OF WORKS, lest any man should boast." (Ephesians 2:8-9) 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I would say Jesus Christ is important but Joseph Smith is very important as well! Did Joseph Smith die for you to pay the penalty for your sin? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

We are the church of Jesus Christ - not the church of a man. Then why do you disagree with Jesus Christ? 

samigale --- 19 years ago -

Did Joseph Smith die for you to pay the penalty for your sin? No, Jesus did. But Joseph Smith plays a big part in what we believe. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

I have a sister and brother in law that are Mormon. I respect them, but I just don't discuss it. There are way too many differences. For me - not discussing it is a problem. You can smile, and pretend differences do not exist, or just be honest with what you think, talk it out, a little uncomfortable at first, but in the end I hope there are not as many differences as you think. My perception is that people do not like us because we claim to have more - a prophet, apostles, more scriptures, more covenants... To me it is taking things from a theoretical - nice ideas sense, to reality.... Not just read the cook book, go out, buy the ingreediants, cook the food, and eat it... Not just read about prophets - but have one. Not just read about the Holy Spirit -but pray and feel it, if that makes sense... That is all I will say on this thread. I am disappointed it is even here, attracting the bashings of people who think they know about my religion... to me - the bashings are already there, why notopen up and talk about the issues instead of being silent, acting like we are trying to hide something? Just talk about things, or leave people suspicious with misconceptions about us - which will it be? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

But Joseph Smith plays a big part in what we believe A larger part than Jesus Christ? 

samigale --- 19 years ago -

My perception is that people do not like us because we claim to have more - a prophet, apostles, more scriptures, more covenants... To me it is taking things from a theoretical - nice ideas sense, to reality.... Not just read the cook book, go out, buy the ingreediants, cook the food, and eat it... Not just read about prophets - but have one. Not just read about the Holy Spirit -but pray and feel it, if that makes sense... Well said Jamie! :) 

samigale --- 19 years ago -

No, but Joseph Smith is important...The Book Of Mormon is just another testament of Jesus Christ...and there is still more to come... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

My perception is that people do not like us because we claim to have more I have nothing against Mormons. I just have a problem with their man-made doctrine when it contradicts God's Word. I have the same problem with ANY doctrine that contradicts God's Doctrine. 

O Nellie --- 19 years ago -

bbjones, you started out very nice and honest. I just want to make sure you take a few deep breaths as you seem to be getting a little hyped. I appreciate your passion though. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground