Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Carbon Dating

who's talking here?

barb 2
freshhell 3
Unichic 2
bbjones 30
boris 1
traveller 2
XCPuff 2
WashingtonYankee 5
jemezchick 5
Neo 1
qpc 1
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 6
ChezML 11
accent_ 7
Mabbers 7
Cicero 15
Reality is good 4

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

I guess Carbon Dating is a lie "It is not a lie but it is only accurate to a maximum of about 40,000 years." Actually it is fairly accurate to 70,000 years. "It has been known since the 1960s that the famous Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary, the line marking the end of the dinosaurs, was 65 million years old. Repeated recalibrations and retests, using ever more sophisticated techniques and equipment, cannot shift that date. It is accurate to within a few thousand years. With modern, extremely precise, methods, error bars are often only 1% or so." Conclusion: Dinosaurs died out long ago and were not present on the Ark.  

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

I married the girl I was Carbon Dating. We're currently living a half-life in the beautiful state of Texas. ha. ha. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Actually it is fairly accurate to 70,000 years. Not so! Actually, carbon dating helps to prove that we live on a young earth - not one that is billions of years old. Let me give you some scientific fact about Carbon 14 dating and the assumptions it is based on. Radiation from the sun strikes the atmosphere of the earth all day long. This energy converts about 21 pounds of nitrogen into radioactive carbon 14. This radioactive carbon 14 slowly decays back into normal, stable nitrogen. Extensive laboratory testing has shown that about half of the C-14 molecules will decay in 5730 years. This is called the half-life. After another 5730 years half of the remaining C-14 will decay leaving only 1/4 of the original C-14. It goes from 1/2 to 1/4 to 1/8, etc. In theory it would never totally disappear, but after about 5 half lives the difference is not measurable with any degree of accuracy. This is why most scientists say carbon dating is only good for objects less than 40,000 years old. NOTHING on Earth carbon dates in the millions of years, because the scope of carbon dating only extends a few thousand years. Willard Libby invented the carbon dating technique in the early 1950's. The amount of carbon 14 in the atmosphere today (about .0000765%), is assumed there would be the same amount found in living plants or animals since the plants breath carbon dioxide and animals eat plants. Carbon 14 is the radio-active version of carbon. Since sunlight causes the formation of C-14 in the atmosphere, and normal radioactive decay takes it out, there must be a point where the formation rate and the decay rate equalizes. This is called the point of equilibrium. C-14 is being formed and decaying simultaneously. A freshly created earth would require about 30,000 years for the amount of C-14 in the atmosphere to reach this point of equilibrium because it would leak out as it is being filled. Tests indicate that the earth has still not reached equilibrium. There is more C-14 in the atmosphere now than there was 40 years ago. This would prove the earth is not yet 30,000 years old! This also means that plants and animals that lived in the past had less C-14 in them than do plants and animals today. Just this one fact totally upsets data obtained by C-14 dating. The carbon in the atmosphere normally combines with oxygen to make carbon dioxide. Plants breathe carbon dioxide and make it part of their tissue. Animals eat the plants and make it part of their tissues. A very small percentage of the carbon plants take in is radioactive C-14. When a plant or animal dies it stops taking in air and food so it should not be able to get any new C-14. The C-14 in the plant or animal will begin to decay back to normal nitrogen. The older an object is, the less carbon-14 it contains. One gram of carbon from living plant material causes a Geiger counter to click 16 times per minute as the C-14 decays. A sample that causes 8 clicks per minute would be 5,730 years old (the sample has gone through one half life), and so on. Although this technique looks good at first, carbon-14 dating rests on two simple assumptions. They are 1) the assumption that the amount of carbon-14 in the atmosphere has always been constant, and 2) that its rate of decay has always been constant. Neither of these assumptions is provable or reasonable. An illustration may help. Imagine you found a candle burning in a room, and you wanted to determine how long it was burning before you found it. You could measure the present height of the candle (say, seven inches) and the rate of burn (say, an inch per hour). In order to find the length of time since the candle was lit, we would be forced to make some assumptions. We would, obviously, have to assume that the candle has always burned at the same rate, and assume that we know the initial height of the candle, which we do not. The answer changes based on the assumptions. Similarly, scientists do not know that the carbon-14 decay rate has been constant. They do not know that the amount of carbon-14 in the atmosphere is constant. In fact, present testing shows the amount of C-14 in the atmosphere has been increasing since it was first measured in the 1950's. This may be tied in to the declining strength of the Earth's magnetic field. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

"It is not a lie but it is only accurate to a maximum of about 40,000 years." And let it be known that by making this statement you agree that the Earth is older than 6,000 years old. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Ok, just so there is no misunderstanding here, I ChezML, stated here, that the dinosaurs became extinct 65 million years ago. You, Jones, state that you agree that: "So just as Noah lived to be 950 years old, their were likely only few reptiles that lived hundreds of years and grew to the size of the T. Rex, we see in museums.) In addition, Noah certainly would have taken young or even baby animals on the ark, not full grown adults of every kind." Please be definative in your response. Do you believe the above. Yes or No, Jones? Inquiring minds want to know. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

Apparently my sense of humor is overcast with another potential thread locker. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

And let it be known that by making this statement you agree that the Earth is older than 6,000 years old. Yes, the earth is more than 6,000 years old. Closer to 6,600 years old. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Yes, the earth is more than 6,000 years old. Closer to 6,600 years old. What has Carbon Dating been used on that has proven the item to be 40,000 years old?? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I believe that Noah lived 950 years. I believe that it is probable that Noah took many animals that were not fully grown on the ark. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

What has Carbon Dating been used on that has proven it to be 40,000 years old?? Nothing. If you would read, the 40,000 year number came from the half-life computations and represents a maximum number that would be accurate. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

This would prove the earth is not yet 30,000 years old! You seem to be confused - you initially said that it was only six thousand years old. Now you are stating yet another number in response to the C dating question. Which is it? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The 30,000 year figure comes from the calculation of the point of equilibrium for C-14 and nitrogen in the atmosphere. That equilibrium will be reached when the earth is approximately 30,000 years old. Since that equilibrium point has not been reached yet, that proves that the earth is less than 30,000 years old and 6,600 years is definitely less than 30,000 years. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Nothing. If you would read, the 40,000 year number came from the half-life computations and represents a maximum number that would be accurate. The isotope carbon-14 (14C) estimates a date up to 60,000 years old]. The guy who discovered C-14 dating was awarded the Nobel prize for chemistry, BTW in the easrly 60's. Jones, show us any C-14 dating results showing dinosaur bones dating to 6K years ago. We're waiting. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Fortunately, there are other radiometric elements. The Earth is ~5 billion years old. No human has lived 950 years, what kind of idiot believes that? We like our nuclear bombs, don't we? We like our nuclear reactors? Why question the half life of the elements that give us this power? Is this the work of the devil???? 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Nothing. If you would read, the 40,000 year number came from the half-life computations and represents a maximum number that would be accurate. I'm not going to get into a creationism discussion with you because it's pointless. But the FACT is that C-Dating HAS been used to PROVE the age of various fossils and bones. And sorry for you, but a great deal are more than 6,600 years old. If you're going to do 'research' then do un-biased research. Look at all sides. And one more thing - stop copying replies from other forums and claiming them as your words. I've seen multiple posts from you now that are simply Copy and Pasted from other internet forums. Tisk, Tisk. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

No human has lived 950 years, what kind of idiot believes that? This kind of idiot. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Extensive laboratory testing has shown that about half of the C-14 molecules will decay in 5730 years. And extensive lab tesing of the element americium-243 has revealed a half-life of 7,370 years. Your theory is going down in flames. Sorry. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Good to know, qpc. 

boris --- 19 years ago -

I am just sorry that some States teach only one side of the story instead of both. Freshhell go girl I am with you. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Jones, show us any C-14 dating results showing dinosaur bones dating to 6K years ago. We're waiting. Jones, You still haven't answered my question. Is it because you can't? Or is it because, you won't? Either reason has it's significance. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

He is watching the Flintstones. Yes, humans and dinos co-existed. Ask the gospel according to Hannah-Barberra! 

WashingtonYankee --- 19 years ago -

Wow, I just learned that I can copy and paste to support any opinion I want also. Some direct criticisms of the C-14 dating technique are: ChristianAnswers.net states: "Outside the range of recorded history, calibration of the 14C clock is not possible." This was true back in the 1950s. A team of researchers, headed by Willard F. Libby calibrated the C-14 measuring technique by comparing the measured age of samples from ancient Egypt with their known date. For example, they tested a piece of wood from Pharaoh Zoser's tomb with the known tomb date, which was known to be circa 2700 to 2600 BCE. The agreement was excellent. Since then, extended calibration checks have been made using U.S. bristlecone pine, German and Irish oak, and other species of trees. That work pushed the calibration back well beyond recorded history to 10,000 BP (years before the present.) Other correlations have extended that to 26,000 years BP. It may eventually go back as far as 45,000 years. The Earth's magnetic field has been decreasing. This will increase the level of cosmic rays in the upper atmosphere, generate more C-14, and upset the C-14 dating process. The earths magnetic field is cyclical in nature. Any affect on the C-14 dating method is corrected by the calibration procedure. The flood of Noah, as described in Genesis, Chapter 6 to 8, would have upset the carbon balance on earth by burying large amounts of carbon containing plants which became coal, and gas. This would lower the total C-12 in the atmosphere at that time and upset the C-14 dating process. The Genesis flood is described in Genesis as occurring circa 2349 BCE. Samples from before, during and after the flood whose dates are known through archaeology have been C-14 tested without any difficulty. Either the worldwide flood of Noah did not happen, or it did not create any significant disturbance in the C-12/C-14 balance at the time. Volcanoes emit a great deal of carbon dioxide which contains very little C-14. Since a massive degree of volcanism occurred during the the flood of Noah, objects which died shortly after the flood would give inaccurate C-14 dating results. Again, C-14 dating results on objects before, during and after the flood were found to be accurate when the data was compared with dates derived from archaeological evidence. If there was a great deal of volcanism in the 23rd century BCE, it does not show up in the C-14 data. Radiocarbon dating laboratories often ask what is the expected age of the samples submitted to them. If C-14 dating is really precise, such information would not be needed. ChristianAnswers.net comments: "Presumably, the laboratories know that anomalous dates are common, so they need some check on whether they have obtained a "good" date." Lab personnel often ask for the approximate age of a specimen in advance of testing, so they can tune their instruments in order to increase the accuracy of the results. They do not ask in order to "cook" the results. Source: Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance (n.d.) Carbon-14 dating (c-14) Beliefs of new-earth creationists. Retrieved May 8 2007 from religioutTolerance.org 

XCPuff --- 19 years ago -

I hate threads like this. This is one of the reasons I stopped posting here almost a year ago. The logic of BBJones is stupid as hell. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

The logic of BBJones is stupid as hell. What logic? 

XCPuff --- 19 years ago -

What logic? oh snap! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I purposely sat back and did not respond because I wanted to see what kind of supposed "scientific" nonsense you guys would post on this forum, especially since you do not understand what you are reading. Sure, I copy and paste some information so that I do not have to spend the time typing, but at least I understand what I am posting. You people are blindly trusting statements that you read in the media or in school books - statements such as "scientists have discovered 65 million year old dinosaur bones in this or that location" or "scientists concluded that a certain rock is 4.5 billion years old". You guys don't even consider questioning the age of these findings because scientists cannot be wrong, or so you are predisposed to believe. But can they be wrong? Everyone has heard about some of the dating methods, like radiocarbon dating, or uranium radiodating. You guys apparently do not know very much about these methods, especially how inaccurate these methods are, and yet they are presented as infallible scientific tools and you believe it to be true without question. You do not seem to understand that these scientists are pulling the wool over your eyes because they have an agenda and most people are too eager to oblige them and believe them without question - you believe them on faith without proof. The funny thing is, this is exactly what you guys say about people who believe in God Almighty. What is the agenda of secular scientists? Their agenda is to have you believe in an evolutionary theory that is being disproved everyday in deference to believing that God was our Creator. Darwin's Theory of Evolution can only occur as a slow gradual process. Darwin wrote, "Natural selection acts only by taking advantage of slight successive variations; she can never take a great and sudden leap, but must advance by short and sure, though slow steps." Darwin also wrote that, "If it could be demonstrated that any complex organ existed, which could not possibly have been formed by numerous, successive, slight modifications, my theory would absolutely break down." Such a complex organ would be known as an "irreducibly complex system". An irreducibly complex system is one composed of multiple parts, all of which are necessary for the system to function. If even one part is missing, the entire system will fail to function. Every individual part is integral. Such a system could not have evolved slowly, piece by piece. Darwin's Theory of Evolution is a theory in crisis in light of the tremendous advances we've made in molecular biology, biochemistry and genetics over the past fifty years. We now know that there are in fact tens of thousands of irreducibly complex systems on the cellular level. But we don't need a microscope to observe irreducible complexity. The eye, the ear and the heart are all examples of irreducible complexity, though they were not recognized as such in Darwin's day. Nevertheless, Darwin himself confessed, "To suppose that the eye with all its inimitable contrivances for adjusting the focus to different distances, for admitting different amounts of light, and for the correction of spherical and chromatic aberration, could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest degree." How do scientist try and keep the fantasy of a failed theory alive? Since evolution has not been observed in our time and it has not been observed in the past either, the only hope remaining for evolutionists is the availability of unimaginably long periods of time and the gullibility of people. Their utmost desire is to demonstrate the existence and scientific validity of these long periods of times. So we come to their use of radiodating. There is a basic pattern that occurs in the decay of radioactive substances. In each of these disintegration systems, the "parent" or original radioactive substance, gradually decays into "daughter" substances and this process is irreversible. The theory asserts that by measuring the amount of parent and daughter elements in a given sample and knowing the decay rate, one might be able to calculate the time elapsed from its formation. These dating methods are seriously flawed because there are too many assumptions that have to be made when performing this process. What makes it worse is that these assumptions are made without any factual evidence. The problems arise because scientists disregard the following truths, which in itself is far from an objective and precise scientific approach. 1) Nobody was there when the world was created to make sure that no daughter products were present in a certain rock, whereas the radiodating method assumes exactly this. It is impossible for anyone to know what had initially been in a given piece of radioactive mineral. 2) The parent and daughter products could easily have been contaminated during their long decay process underground. For the results to be accurate, the systems had to be closed during the decay process, but this doesn't happen in nature. It can only occur in a laboratory. 3) The decay rate is not constant. Environmental factors, such as pressure, changes in cosmic radiation level, nearby radioactive materials, high temperatures influence decay rate. In one of their studies, Westinghouse Laboratories have been able to change decay rates simply by placing inactive iron next to radioactive lead. 4) Part of the radioactive substances could have been leached out. Experiments show that even distilled water and weak acids can do this. 5) Rocks could have been altered by sediment displacements. 6) Laboratories that "date" rocks insist on knowing in advance the "evolutionary age" of the strata from which the samples were taken. That is nothing more than circular dating. Here are a few examples of the accuracy of radiodating: - Hawaiian lava flows known to be less than two centuries old have been dated at up to 3 billion years old - mortar from the 785 year old Oxford Castle in England was dated at 7,370 years old - freshly killed seals were dated at 1,300 years and seals dead for 30 years at 4,600 years - living snails being dated at 2,300 years old - new wood cut from growing trees after few days was dated at 10,000 years - muscle tissue from beneath the scalp of a mummified musk was dated to 24,000 years, while the the radiocarbon age of hair from a hind limb was established to be 17,200 years - hair from a mammoth has been dated at 26,000 years while the peat right above the carcass at only 5,610 years My logic comes from God knowing that He created the universe and not from men who have to make faulty assumptions and use improper scientific method in their attempt to prove the flawed theory of an uninformrd man. If you people were scientists, some of you would realize the hoax that is being perpetrated on you by these scientists to further their agenda of keeping people from believing in God. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

Mr. jones would like to thank www.cryingvoice.com and www.allaboutscience.org for the previous post. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I put the previous post together. It does not matter where the information comes from, it is the validity of the information that is important. I even gave a disclaimer in the post, which apparently you ignored, that said "Sure, I copy and paste some information so that I do not have to spend the time typing, but at least I understand what I am posting." Did you understand what was posted? 

traveller --- 19 years ago -

bbjones, as a scientist I am flabbergasted that you can believe the earth being 6000 years old; Noah or any man living 950 years. We've had this discussion before and it never ceases to amaze me. So I guess all the other stars and galaxies are 6000 years old? Even though they are millions of light years away? 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

Noah or any man living 950 years. It's part of the Bible, which is God's inspired Word and I believe it and other Christians believe it. It's MY faith and you certainly have the right to question it. But I also have the right to defend it. I'd rather look like a foolish Christian than an intelligent Greek. (Of course, you probably won't get THAT reference). I take a lot of my Christianity on faith. Burdens of proof will be sought after time and time again with little or no delivery. I guess the believers and nonbelievers will argue the age of the earth until the end of it. However, it's not how old the earth is that is the point. It's where we go afterward that IS. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Reason and science are not going to impact this debate. This debate is not about reason and science and facts. 

traveller --- 19 years ago -

shutterman, Did God actually write the old testament?? He didn't actually put pen tp paper (or Papyrus),someone with supposed divine inspiration did. That's the safety net for all of you who believe the bible word for word. Everything was written by u>manu> with divine inspiration. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

So I guess all the other stars and galaxies are 6000 years old? Even though they are millions of light years away? Yes, they are traveller. God does not specifically say "This is how I did it", but the following explanation is inferred in Scripture. The first thing God did was to create "the heaven and the earth" (Genesis 1:1). This shows that the earth, where God would put man - His greatest creation, was the center of creation. The stars were not created until day 4. We are told in Isaiah 42:5 "Thus saith God the LORD, he that created the heavens, and stretched them out;" So, if the earth was the center of God's creation and God stretched out the heavens, which contained the stars, then as the stars were being pulled away, then the light beams would be stretched also. So in a sense, you have been looking at the Creation in the reverse manner than it happened. It does amaze me that when you were ill, your wife was asking for prayers from God - a being that you apparently do not want to believe. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Reason and science are not going to impact this debate. This debate is not about reason and science and facts. This debate has plenty of scientific fact. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

This debate has plenty of scientific fact. No, bbjones, it doesn't. There's no place for it with you. It is wasted with you. There are those in KU with whom it would be fun and enlightening and challenging to engage in a debate about the tools that God used in Creation and how real science and the Bible are not in conflict, but you insist on so dominating any such discussion by volume of posts and by darkness of mood that those other KUers, who appear to share many of your views, are seldom heard. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

I have petrified wood in my garden that is older than 40,000 years. the creationism theory (earth is only 6600 years old) is a fallacy at best. Documentation to back it up...none needed... Any REASONABLE person knows the earth is older than 6600 years. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

There are those in KU with whom it would be fun and enlightening and challenging to engage in a debate about the tools that God used in Creation and how real science and the Bible are not in conflict, but you insist on so dominating any such discussion by volume of posts and by darkness of mood that those other KUers, who appear to share many of your views are seldom heard. How do you come up with this nonsense? What does your post have to do with scientific fact? By the way, I am not stopping anyone from posting. What "darkness of mood" are you talking about? Are you some kind of goth person? If you do not like what I post, then I have a cure for you. Just do not read what I post. 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground